When it comes to studies - you mostly adopt any one of the techniques of Studying - either Learning with Understanding or cram without Understanding.
It has always been a debate - on what is better -
Reading (Learning / पठन / વાંચન )
OR
Cramming (Mugging/ रठना / ગોખમ્પટ્ટી)
Similarly when it comes to Music - i wonder - is the conventional singing with live supporting hands (Table/ Harmonium) better or the new concept of (stand alone) Karaoke singing?
So my question to all my Friends out there is -
To whom would your preferential vote go
Learning - Conventional Live Singing
OR
Cramming - Karoke Singing!
Just wanted to know what is the take of the fellow musical lovers out here in this group about the increasing craze for Karaoke singing amongst Music professionals.
I personally feel that Karoke is not for trained singers - it definitely is a very good tool for those who are interested in music and want to sing for their own enjoyment and satisfaction.
Trained singers are expected to deliver a song with his / her own touch of magic to the song - which i think cannot be done on a pre-recorded or the original sound track!
If all singers started singing on Karaoke - where would the accompanying artists and instrumentalists go!
With all due respects to the technological developments - but technology everywhere sometimes makes the original charm fade away.
Reproduction of something as same as Original is definitely worth appreciating but if that was so did Jagjit ji always sing kagaz ki kashti in the same (xerox copy style) in every concert? Was ever Jai Ho always the same every time when AR Rehman presented - was there no variation in the lifts when Adnan sami sang Lift kara de....
The versatility of a singer can be measured by the variations that he can bring in his presentations...
Ireally felt disappointed while reading a comment in one of the social network that someone had posted about a live concert of a very well known great artist - a living legend - it said "प्रोग्राम में ख़ास मज़ा नहीं आया, क्यों की ____ ने फिल्म मे है वैसे नहीं गया - काफी अलग अलग variations के साथ और अलग अंदाज़ के साथ उस गाने को गया था "
How Ridiculous! If at all you wanted to hear the same - ditto copy as it is sung in the movies - then why do you have to spend for the ticket and go for the live concert - you can very well hear it on the CD / DVD!!!
So wake up dear revered artists - let us not blindly follow something that has started just because it is a faster way to succeed - a personal touch every where does a lots of magic & wonders!
It has always been a debate - on what is better -
Reading (Learning / पठन / વાંચન )
OR
Cramming (Mugging/ रठना / ગોખમ્પટ્ટી)
Similarly when it comes to Music - i wonder - is the conventional singing with live supporting hands (Table/ Harmonium) better or the new concept of (stand alone) Karaoke singing?
So my question to all my Friends out there is -
To whom would your preferential vote go
Learning - Conventional Live Singing
OR
Cramming - Karoke Singing!
Just wanted to know what is the take of the fellow musical lovers out here in this group about the increasing craze for Karaoke singing amongst Music professionals.
I personally feel that Karoke is not for trained singers - it definitely is a very good tool for those who are interested in music and want to sing for their own enjoyment and satisfaction.
Trained singers are expected to deliver a song with his / her own touch of magic to the song - which i think cannot be done on a pre-recorded or the original sound track!
If all singers started singing on Karaoke - where would the accompanying artists and instrumentalists go!
With all due respects to the technological developments - but technology everywhere sometimes makes the original charm fade away.
Reproduction of something as same as Original is definitely worth appreciating but if that was so did Jagjit ji always sing kagaz ki kashti in the same (xerox copy style) in every concert? Was ever Jai Ho always the same every time when AR Rehman presented - was there no variation in the lifts when Adnan sami sang Lift kara de....
The versatility of a singer can be measured by the variations that he can bring in his presentations...
Ireally felt disappointed while reading a comment in one of the social network that someone had posted about a live concert of a very well known great artist - a living legend - it said "प्रोग्राम में ख़ास मज़ा नहीं आया, क्यों की ____ ने फिल्म मे है वैसे नहीं गया - काफी अलग अलग variations के साथ और अलग अंदाज़ के साथ उस गाने को गया था "
How Ridiculous! If at all you wanted to hear the same - ditto copy as it is sung in the movies - then why do you have to spend for the ticket and go for the live concert - you can very well hear it on the CD / DVD!!!
So wake up dear revered artists - let us not blindly follow something that has started just because it is a faster way to succeed - a personal touch every where does a lots of magic & wonders!
No comments:
Post a Comment